Boy buys DVD. Boy can’t play DVD on his PC. Boy writes code to play DVD on PC. Boy is put on trial.
How do you explain to lay people why the DMCA is wrong? Do people care that movie production companies do not want to allow them to play their own DVDs on “unauthorized” equipment? Recently, the MPAA coerced Norway to prosecute a teenager for breaking the encryption on a DVD that he owned. Norway doesn’t even have a DMCA-like law and the MPAA had to twist the interpretation of current law to get the prosecution. Hopefully their court systems have some sense.
What really got me to thinking about this was this analysis by Andy Oram. Many people who are against the DMCA claim that congress didn’t really intend for it to be this bad. Andy makes the case that these rulings are exactly what Congress’s intention was. For example, because of the ruling against 2600, this link (snatched from the Gallery of DeCSS code) is illegal because what it points to is directly compilable code that can be used to decrypt encrypted DVDs.
Yes, the what the link points to is illegal, but the link itself is also illegal. So says the Second Circuit Court. In fact, in his write-up, Andy says that when the EFF pointed to the part of the DMCA that says “Nothing in this section shall enlarge or diminish any rights of free speech“, the court replied “Congress could not ‘diminish’ constitutional rights of free speech even if it wished to.“
They then proceded to show that the courts are the ones with the right to take away free speech (I missed that in my Civics class, I guess) by limiting speech through source code, even though other court cases had established that code is speech and not limitable. They also limited linking (as in the above).
Are people incensed by this? Are people upset? Sure, us geeks are, but that seems to be about it. The general public seems ambivilent. Or do I simply judge the interest of the general public by what is shown on TV — a medium that can’t be trusted in this instance because the owners of television are the members of the MPAA. Or, would more people be interested if they knew, but they don’t know because their primary source of information is the television?
Argh! I’m running into a hard-to-reproduce bug with Mozilla. It crashes sometimes when I’m editting in a <textarea>.
Check out the images on girlrepair.com. Beautiful!
From Tom’s Hardware, via Jonathon Delacour: Water Coolers. When this is what it takes to run your computer, don’t you think it is a bit too warm?
From Kamat AnthoBLOGy: “How I Fought the Programmer’s Disease“
In year 2000, a fellow programmer suggested that I switch my mouse-clicking hand.
I did this while I was at Tulane. It works!
While I was looking for information on Sun and SCSI devices, I noticed an additional nav-bar appeared when I went to this page. “Previous”, “Next”, etc. Evidently it is looking at the <link> tags in the document. Cool.
Evidently this has been there since last october but I never noticed. Ok, I admit, I’ve only begun using Mozilla again.
Totally exhausted tonight.
I was supposed to swap a tape drive on one of the machines. That went off ok (but Sun really shouldn’t change device names if the position on the SCSI chain changes — headache!).
But then the monitoring system started noticing some funny log messages. I found out more aout Big Brother than I really wanted to tonight. One good thing: it appears to expire messages after an hour or so. Didn’t seem to do that before. We’ll see. It is still paging me so I turned off my pager.
When it first started paging me, I was sitting right there and ignored it. Yep… I knew the systems were down. Then it stopped (or so I thought), so I finished up and headed home.
I was about a mile away when it started again. I had just crossed the bridge over I-10 and had to turn around and ride back over the bridge. Then I rode over it again to come back home. Ugh… My poor legs.
Ok, enough… Now I just want to get packages with Grub and XFS, 2.4.14 kernel with XFS, and bricolage.
This blog by a native of India. Kamat’s Potpourri: Kamat AnthoBLOGy
I see the same scenario in the subcontinent now. India is just waiting for another terrorist attack to declare the offensive. The situation is very fluid.
Musharaf knows this very well. Why else do you think he is reversing twenty years of Pakistani policies? A war will certainly leave him out of power.
Also interesting is his reasoning for building his own blogger software.
Now this is intersting: From mpt‘s faq page:
By day, I work for a pittance at an Internet cafe in Christchurch, New Zealand.
By night, I work for free on user interface design for the Mozilla Project, trying to bring Mozilla to a state where a majority of the world
Great. Now I’ve got to follow his blog to understand why he doesn’t have a “real” job.